TEXAS TENORS &
THE BIG BEAT
By Marshall Bowden
Texas is a miniature of the cultural and musical
melting pot that is American music. Texas shares a border
with Louisiana, inheriting some of that state's French and
Caribbean roots, and when it comes to the blues, Texas has
its own style. Texas blues is not like Delta blues or Chicago
blues or blues from the other southern states. Texas blues
is a stylistic mélange made by musicians from backgrounds
as varied as you can imagine: Mance Lipscomb, Lightnin'
Hopkins, Big Mama Thornton, Clarence "Gatemouth"
Brown, and Pee Wee Crayton are just a few of Texas' widely
varied blues performers.
Texas turned the roadhouse into a cottage
industry, with its country ethos and rock n' roll bad boy
subtext. The state has inherited a vast array of music—country,
blues, cowboy songs, Cajun, Mexican, R&B, Rock &
Roll. Hell, Texas even has its very own gumbo—chili!!
Texas has another musical tradition, the Texas tenor. The
Texas tenor is a tenor sax slinger with a sound as wide
open and freewheeling as the Lone Star State. Honed by blues
influences, able to honk and walk the bar with the best
of the R&B tenor men, sharpened by the study of jazz
greats Lester Young and Ben Webster, with a sprinkling of
Coleman Hawkins. Some of them weren't even born in Texas
and many ended up somewhere else, but they all were stamped
by a similar configuration of influences that allowed listeners
to discern a unique set of voices on the jazz horizon. These
musicians and their recordings have given me some of my
most pleasurable listening moments, but you won't hear about
them in most educational programs or read about them in
many of the jazz histories at your local bookstore. That's
largely because they did one thing and did it well—they
could swing hard, play beautifully, and execute ideas that
connect instantly with the listener without making any stylistic
concessions.
In many ways Arnett Cobb
sounds the closest to Lester Young—just listen to
his playing on the recent Prestige reissue Movin'
Right Along, and particularly to his work on the
track "Softly, As In a Morning Sunrise." His statement
of the melody and solo rely on a total relaxation, a flirting
with the beat that demonstrates the improvisor's impenetrable
armor of cool. Then, on the following track, "Fast
Ride" he'd playing a rablle-rousing Illinois Jacquet-style
R&B intro before launching into a near-KC swing groove
(it's just a bit too fast) that again recalls Young. The
fat, open sound that most of the Texas tenors use is a more
muscular sound than that of Young, but Cobb is capable of
affecting much the same tone of urbane sophistication as
Lester.
Interestingly, Cobb was Illinois Jacquet's
replacement in Lionel Hampton's band, playing with the group
from 1942 until 1947. He took over the tenor solo in Hampton's
classic piece "Flying Home", which had made Jacquet
famous. Cobb reworked the solo and became almost as famous
for it as Jacquet had, even recording "Flying Home
No. 2" with Hampton. Like Jacquet before him, Cobb
became known as a "wild man" and was encouraged
to play histrionic shrieks and squawks. While he was quite
popular, Cobb's talent as a unique tenor saxophonist was
largely overlooked during this period. He was sidelined
by a spinal operation and illness from 1948 to around 1951.
In 1956 or '57 (sources vary) he had a near-fatal car crash
and was told he would not play again. He had already recorded
several sessions for Prestige, and these continued to be
released during his recuperation. Soon he was again playing
and recording for Prestige, and his new recordings demonstrated
that he was more than, in Leroi Jones' words, "an old
swinging work horse stomper." Listen to the heartbreaking
beauty of Cobb's interpretation of "(I Don't Stand)
A Ghost of a Chance (With You)" and you'll forget about
the "wild man" moniker forever.
Illinois Jacquet recorded
his famous solo on Hampton's "Going Home" when
he was just 19 years old. He continued to work with Hampton
until he supposedly realized, one night in Detroit that
people were coming to hear him as much as they were coming
to hear the Hampton band. Afterward he worked with Cab Calloway
and Count Basie while leading his own successful groups
on the side. From 1950 on he was a principal soloist with
Norman Granz's Jazz at the Philharmonic tours, and he later
toured Europe with Arnett Cobb and Buddy Tate as Texas Tenors.
Just like Cobb, Jacquet became known initially as a saxophone
"wild man" who could drive audiences into a frenzy
by playing squeaks, squawks, and prolonged high notes. This
was due, in part, to the nature of the Jazz at the Philharmonic
audience, which was not generally an audience of jazz aficionados
but rather the general public. They came to see a blowing
session and, as Granz himself noted, the concerts were selling
excitement, not music. On his own, Jacquet became a much
mellower player, working with small groups and his own Jazz
Legends big band. His work on ballads is transcendent and
often echoes the work of Coleman Hawkins, who certainly
influenced Jacquet.
James Clay was another Texas
tenor who is perhaps best known for his long service in
Ray Charles' band. Clay retired after a decade with Charles,
but later returned, playing with Billy Higgins in the 1980s.
He also rehearsed with Ornette Coleman in Los Angeles in
the 1950s and is sometimes said to have influenced Coleman,
though he has never played anything remotely like the free
jazz sound that Coleman made famous. On his debut Riverside
recording, The
Sound of Wide Open Spaces!!! (also Cannonball Adderley's
debut as a producer; he "discovered" Clay in L.A.)
it is usually accepted that Clay is overshadowed by the
work of fellow Texas sax player David "Fathead"
Newman as well as by Wynton Kelly's hyper-swinging piano
work. Perhaps, but one must remember that Clay was only
24 at the time of this recording, and that he is much more
bebop influenced than Newman. In general, this is not a
groundbreaking recording, but much more of a blowing session—if
you heard this performance in a nightclub, you would not
feel you'd wasted your evening at all. On the later Cookin'
at the Continental Clay is commanding and every
bit the equal of Newman, and the recording also features
solid performances by trumpeter Roy Hargrove and bassist
Christian McBride.
David "Fathead" Newman
is a giant presence in the annals of Texas musicians and
has worked in a variety of performing and recording situations
including R&B bands, small group work, backing vocalists,
and big bands. Newman was influenced early on by Louis Jordan
and later by Basie sideman Buster Smith. He preceded James
Clay in Ray Charles' band and has continued to be a presence
in the recording studio and on the music scene right up
until today. His work on the recording Bluesiana,
a collaboration between Newman, drummer Art Blakey, and
pianist Mac Rebennack (Dr. John) is excellent, as is his
playing on his two recordings with Clay, The
Sound of Wide Open Spaces!!! and Cookin'
at the Continental. Other standout recordings include
Fathead—Ray
Charles Presents David Newman, Straight
Ahead, and House
of David.
Buddy Tate first came to
notice as a member of the original Count Basie band in the
1930s. Tate was influenced primarily by Ben Webster, Coleman
Hawkins, and Herschel Evans, who he replaced in Basie's
band. Tate had the big Texas tenor sound, and he also distinguished
himself with his clarinet playing. A native of Sherman,
TX, Tate played in bands led by such jazz luminaries as
Hot Lips Page, Jimmy Rushing, and Andy Kirk. He toured into
the '70s with Benny Goodman, Jay McShann, and fellow tenor
saxophonist Paul Quinichette. A particularly interesting
and excellent recording by Tate is Buddy
Tate Meets Abdullah Ibrahim: The Legendary 1977 Encounter,
on which Tate plays with the verve and vigor of a man half
his age, and Ibrahim provides swinging and sympathetic accompaniment.
Also worth checking out is the recording Milt
Buckner/Illinois Jacquet/Buddy Tate, on which the
two Texas tenor men play with legendary swing organist Buckner.
Dewey Redman came from a
different generation of players, but he has the unmistakable
hallmarks of the Texas tenor: an open, big sound, inventiveness,
and a fierce independence. Though Redman moved to California
before he was well known, he found his niche collaborating
with another Lone Star graduate, Ornette Coleman. Redman
recorded some excellent work with Coleman, drummer Elvin
Jones, and bassist Jimmy Garrison. He has also worked with
Charlie Haden and the Liberation Orchestra, Carla Bley,
and Keith Jarrett. He played on such pivotal Jarrett recordings
as Survivors
Suite and Fort
Yawuh. Much of his earlier work is now back in
print, and standouts include Ear
of the Behearer, recorded right as Redman was winding
up his association with Ornette Coleman, and Tarik,
a trio recording featuring drummer Ed Blackwell and bassist
Malachi Favors. Redman, who is the father of young tenor
star Joshua Redman, is far too often overlooked in the annals
of jazz tenor sax players, despite his skill with forms
that included bebop, the blues, music from other cultures,
and his own unique style.