Melody Gardot is one of those talents that comes along from time to time
which is totally out of step with what the recording industry considers
‘hip’ or ‘popular’ at the time, but who nonetheless
succeed over time due to the complete honesty of that talent. Her debut
disc, Worrisome Heart, brings to mind, variously, Rickie Lee
Jones, Bette Midler, Leon Redbone, Madeleine Peyroux, Nick Drake—all
musical originals, like Gardot herself. Melody grew up playing piano in
Philadelphia piano bars and clubs from the age of 16. This no doubt influenced
the effortless, late-nite vibe that characterizes her work on Worrisome
Heart, a vibe that hides the incredible effort that Gardot has put
into writing and performing this music.
At 19, Gardot suffered a host of physical and neurologic
injuries when she was hit by a car while riding her bicycle. She continues
to suffer pain and disability from a broken pelvis, requiring her to use
a cane as well as a special unit that uses electric impulses to distract
her body from chronic pain, wears dark glasses to counteract continued
photosensitivity, and suffers from short term memory loss. But her focus
is on her continued ability to make music: “Two years later (after
the accident), to date, I was sitting in the cutting room surrounded by
incredible musicians with the opportunity of a lifetime. Part of me still
doesn’t believe it.”
All of the songs on Worrisome Heart are originals,
revealing Gardot to be a very talented songwriter. Some will no doubt
hear a bit of a Norah Jones vibe here, and that’s not completely
off the mark, but Gardot seems to offer a bit more overall passion and
soul to her delivery here. While Gardot is not really a jazz singer, her
vocal style is shot through with blues and late-nite cabaret singing,
recalling bluesy white singers like Peggy Lee. At the same time, her languid
style is not really in step with what is the most popular mainstream style
these days. She sounds timeless, neither wholly retro nor contemporary,
with the ability to exist between worlds in the best possible way.
Gardot invites comparisons with some contemporary (or at
least modern) singer/songwriters, and it’s worth noting that most
of them are (or were) considered mavericks. Because of the intimate nature
of her music, one cannot help but hear traces of Finoa Apple, Nick Drake,
and Jeff Buckley here, but then, Gardot is not like any of them, she simply
exists in her own musical world the way that they did. The sheer beauty
of songs like “Love Me Like a River Does” or “Sweet
Memory” or the title track is conveyed in lyrics that are simple
and direct and performances that are equally uncluttered. Worrisome
Heart is the debut of a major talent, and should be heard by everyone
who loves an understated, late-nite vibe and talent that states, rather
than screams, its case.