1. Giant
Steps: It's still amazing to hear
Coltrane rip through the two-to-the-bar chord changes on
the title track, while songs like "Naima" and
"Syeeda's Song Flute" demonstrate Tranes' continued
interest in the modal experiments he encountered on Miles
Davis' Kind of Blue sessions.
2. A
Love Supreme: Coltrane's supreme
spiritual statement, and for many his most coherent musical
statement as well. A four-part suite based on a four-note
motif that rises and falls as Coltrane and pianist McCoy
Tyner spin out from the strong kick of rhythm players Jimmy
Garrison and Elvin Jones. One of jazz's best selling recordings
of all time.
3. Blue
Train: Coltrane was signed with Prestige
when he recorded this one-off album for Blue Note, and concern
for any legal ramifications is demonstrated in the use of
"Train" rather than "Trane" in the title.
The album is a joy to listen to, featuring well-constructed
solos and swinging work from a sharp rhythm section. Truly
a classic recording, well balanced between hard bop numbers
and intimate ballads.
4. Complete
1961 Village Vanguard Recordings: On
the Vanguard 1961 dates, Trane's musical conception was
already opening up considerably from that demonstrated on
Giant Steps. Some of the more frenetic tendencies in his
playing, muted in the recording studio environment, came
to the fore in live performance. His quartet was already
developing the searching, moody, introspective yet physically
punchy and demanding music that would earn it a mystique
nearly unrivaled in the jazz canon. And the group had a
secret weapon at these performances-Eric Dolphy.
5. My
Favorite Things: Similar in some respects
to Giant Steps, but with longer, more modal numbers
and the debut of Trane's soprano saxophone work, which came
as the result of his listening to Sydney Bechet and his
awareness of Steve Lacy's work with Monk.
6. Ballads:
Following his first Impulse! releases and
the performances at the Village Vanguard in 1961, Coltrane
was severly taken to task by many critics for engaging in
what they termed "anti-jazz." Eric Dolphy departed
the group and Coltrane recorded this now-classic collection
of ballads. The album, which demonstrates that Coltrane
was one of jazz's great interpreters of ballads, has been
rediscovered since singer Karrin Allyson recorded vocal
versions of the same songs on her Ballads: Remembering
John Coltrane.
7. Complete
Africa/Brass Sessions: One of Coltrane's
first projects with the Impulse! label, this unique recording
features Eric Dolphy's arrangements for a large group of
brass and reeds that reaches 13 pieces on some tracks. The
arrangements are beautiful and majestic, matching the intensity
of Coltrane's solo work and the searing drumming of Elvin
Jones.
8. Coltrane
Plays the Blues: These tracks were done
at the same sessions in October of 1960 that netted the
Favorite Things album, and the material here is every
bit as good, though not as well known. The famous Coltrane
Quartet was just beginning to gel, and McCoy Tyner's contributions
in particular are an indication of what was to come. Coltrane
demonstrates an emotional committment to the blues form
on this album that isn't really heard anywhere else, and
it is also amazing to hear the things he could do harmonically
with the very structured form.
9. Classic
Quartet: Complete Impulse! Studio Recordings: OK,
maybe it's cheating to include this along with some of the
individual albums, but if you were to buy only one John
Coltrane collection, this is the one you'd have to have.
Everything done by the quartet between 1961 and 1965 is
here on this 8-CD set, and it is breathtaking. This music
stands with the best in jazz--Louis Armstrong's Hot Fives
and Hot Sevens, the original Bill Evans Trio, and both of
Miles Davis' classic quintets.
10. John
Coltrane and Johnny Hartman: Another
of Coltrane's more conservative albums that followed the
critical attacks on his 1961 work. Johnny Hartman's voice
is the perfect match for Coltrane's tenor sound, and the
songs are great, especially the rendition of "Lush
Life".