The three musicians who comprise BeatleJazz
have a few important things in common. None has limited
himself to the jazz mainstream, choosing instead to develop
in ways that they find personally satisfying. All have been
influenced by music from outside American culture, particularly
Latin and Afro-Cuban rhythms. And all three--pianist Dave
Kikoski, drummer Brian Melvin, and bassist Charles Fambrough--have
become successful musicians in their own right, all thriving
in a business that can be difficult to negotiate.
The two BeatleJazz recordings, A Bite of
the Apple and Another Bite of the Apple, are
successful attempts to use the melodies of the Beatles as
jumping-off points for both group exploration and solo improvisation.
The arrangements are simple yet elegant, neither slavishly
sticking to a song's original concept and feel nor introducing
novelty merely for its own sake. Their performances on these
discs demonstrate something else as well: the enduring nature
of the songs penned by John Lennon, Paul McCartney, and
George Harrison, and the beautiful melodic conception of
these songwriters in particular. Most of the songs are harmonically
straightforward, being popular tunes, but this poses no
problem for these inventive musicians. Some songs, like
"I'll Follow the Sun" get the jazz-chord substitution
treatment while others respond quite nicely to a modal treatment
("Magical Mystery Tour").
Dave Kikoski, the pianist of BeatleJazz, has
a strong jazz background, having been taught to play Basie
and Ellington right along with Beethoven by his father,
a part-time musician. Kikoski studied at Berklee College
of Music, playing no only in jazz bands but also in funk
and rock groups. After graduating, he spent some time in
Boston and Argentina (his wife's native country). Returning
to the states, he began playing weddings, bar mitzvahs,
and clubs around New Jersey and Long Island. "The groups
on those gigs were pretty good, better than on some jazz
gigs" he opines, "and shit could be happening
even when it was an R&B cover tune at a bar mitzvah."
Shortly thereafter Kikoski was working with Roy Haynes and
Randy Brecker as well as having an album (Persistent
Dreams) produced by Steely Dan's Walter Becker.
Brian Melvin, who conceived the BeatleJazz
project, wanted to be a drummer since the moment he saw
the Beatles on the Ed Sullivan Show. He got a drum set for
Christmas and was off and running. He became interested
in the music of the Grateful Dead, a band that featured
two drummer/percussionists and helped introduce Melvin to
the world of improvisational music. That led him to the
Keystone Korner club where he listened closely to every
jazz drummer who played, and became friends with many, including
Elvin Jones, Art Blakey, Max Roach, Philly Joe Jones, Billy
Higgins, and Buddy Rich. He became especially good friends
with Rich, a friendship that lasted throughout the remainder
of Rich's life. Brian also spent a year and a half with
drummer Al Foster as his roommate, a time that he remembers
fondly as a major period in his development as a drummer.
Brian has also studied with many master percussionists from
outside the United States, including Tabla masters Allah
Rhaka and Zakir Hussain, African drummer Kwaku Daddy, and
Cuban percussionist Armando Peraza. Melvin has also worked
with the Grateful Dead's Bob Weir, Greg Allman, and bassist
Jaco Pastorius, with whom he toured and recorded extensively.
He has also written a book entitled The Tao of Drumming.
Bassist Charles Fambrough has played with a variety of jazz
luminaries including McCoy Tyner, Grover Washington, Jr.,
Art Blakey, Flora Purim, and Airto. He is also well known
as a composer, combining jazz, Latin, and Brazilian grooves
to create a music that falls outside the usual labels and
constrictions of mainstream jazz. As a composer, he's definitely
been influenced by the music of Wayne Shorter and Herbie
Hancock, because, he says, "serious musicians at some
point have to investigate Wayne Shorter and Herbie Hancock."
Fambrough also points out that "The musicians that
I aspire to, the record company is insignificant to them.
Their development, individual growth and viewpoint (is important)."
Charles has certainly chosen a wide variety of paths in
his development, playing with not only the best jazz musicians,
but popular artists such as George Benson and Donny Hathaway
as well.
Melvin first worked together with bassist
Fambrough and pianist Kikoski back in 1989 when they had
a year-long stint as house rhythm section for the after
hours jam sessions at the Blue Note nightclub in New York.
The idea for BeatleJazz, says Melvin, has been fermenting
for quite a while. "I've been fooling around with this
concept for a good 15 years. I've been putting on concerts
here with my own trio in San Francisco for all that time,
sneaking in a new arrangement of a Beatles tune here and
there. So this thing has taken shape over time and has finally
come to fruition through this trio with David and Charles."
To be honest, I enjoyed the newer disc, Another
Bite of the Apple, a bit more than its predecessor,
but that was really due more to the tune selection than
to the approach. Besides the aforementioned tunes, the album
includes a lovely "Here, There, and Everywhere"
on which Brian Melvin's brushwork is great and Kikoski uses
chord substitutions that emphasize the beauty of the melody
rather than the rising nature of the chord progression.
"Let It Be" gets a reggae treatment, with Fambrough's
bass leading the way both rhythmically and harmonically.
He also takes a solo turn that is one of the disc's high
points. George Harrison's "Give Me Love" achieves
a sort of gospel feeling, while the arrangement of "Michelle"
bypasses the corniness of the pseudo-French melody by half-timing
the chorus and playing the verse with delicacy, using the
chord structure to suggest the melody rather than stating
it outright.
Both "Magical Mystery Tour" and
"Tomorrow Never Knows" become full-fledged modal
workouts, with the latter highlighting some of Brian Melvin's
non-traditional percussion skills. The disc passes pleasantly
and is over almost before you know it. Fab Four favorites
like "Blackbird" are slowed down dramatically,
while trippy tunes such as "Blue Jay Way" are
unexpectedly speeded up to bebop tempos. The first disc
is every bit as pleasant and rewarding an experience, with
songs like "Come Together", "Eleanor Rigby",
"I Am the Walrus", and "Mother Nature's Son"
getting the BeatleJazz treatment.
BeatleJazz could easily have degenerated into
a smooth-jazz attempt to cash in on the popularity of the
Beatles' music. In the hands of these three able and experienced
jazz musicians, it is instead an exploration of these familiar
songs that brings unexpected elements to the fore and demonstrates
that they are open to an infinite number of interpretations.
Roll up, kids. Roll up for the mystery tour.